Welcome to Collingwood, Derek Hine

[Jez07]

Hine is getting sacked

[thompsoc]

Karl Langdon saying on 3aw that Gubby is replacing Hine who is being demoted

If true and I say if true.
It makes the almost ridiculous support by a whole army of Nicksters of Hine look a little off.
Hine was ok but his record never ever demanded such motto's as "In Hine we trust" and "Hine is a genius".

[CarringbushCigar]

Hine is getting sacked

Leaving the club ? When ?

[Presti35]

I think our bigger stuff ups was the 2014 draft.

2014 -
Pick 5 - DeGoey (fail)

The following were available to us and will be better players than DeGoey:
6- Caleb Marchbank
8- Peter Wright
10- Nakia Cockatoo
14- Jake Lever

I just think we overlooked too much class and went with DeGoey who was a hard nut, but footy is about speed and class these days.

HUGE call.

[jatsad]

I think our bigger stuff ups was the 2014 draft.

2014 -
Pick 5 - DeGoey (fail)

The following were available to us and will be better players than DeGoey:
6- Caleb Marchbank
8- Peter Wright
10- Nakia Cockatoo
14- Jake Lever

I just think we overlooked too much class and went with DeGoey who was a hard nut, but footy is about speed and class these days.

Lever I may understand but I think he's got the others covered.
As a lot of young players, second year blues may have him. Being in a crap system also doesn't help.

[didick]

I think our bigger stuff ups was the 2014 draft.

2014 -
Pick 5 - DeGoey (fail)

The following were available to us and will be better players than DeGoey:
6- Caleb Marchbank
8- Peter Wright
10- Nakia Cockatoo
14- Jake Lever

I just think we overlooked too much class and went with DeGoey who was a hard nut, but footy is about speed and class these days.

Lever I may understand but I think he's got the others covered.
As a lot of young players, second year blues may have him. Being in a crap system also doesn't help.

Yep, I agree. I'm backing in The Goo.

[Redlight]

Karl Langdon saying on 3aw that Gubby is replacing Hine who is being demoted

Karl Langdon.

OK then.

[inxs88]

So Langdon is doing a "Sandra Sully" with the late news here. Hey peroxide toss bag, I too can read the Age newspaper on Tuesday and get on radio and claim it as my own!!!!

[Bob Sugar]

If true and Hine is being demoted does that mean Rendal loses his job?

[Jez07]

Geelong beat us in a GF with an older side, have had more retirements than us since and now are a flag contender.

Our club has failed massively due to Hine and recruiting.

[ronrat]

I still wake up in a cold sweat from time to time, imagining myself at the Western Oval again, watching as Gubby kicks the ball directly to the opposition FF with Collingwood a point in front and the final siren about to go....

Gubby was ahead of his time. Just didn't execute properly. The switch across goals happens 20 times a game these days. Back then it was tantamount to murder.

watch hockey and soccer and you will see similarities and things that have been borrowed from those games.

banksy ttook an absolute screamer and promptly kicked it OOF from close i n. They never should have been that close but the umpires murdered us early on. My mate nearly got us into a punch up when he yelled out"Do you have to be a meatworker to get a free kick here".

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

De Goey a fail? Did I just go through the freaking looking glass? This place is getting more bizarre by the day

[woftam]

I think our bigger stuff ups was the 2014 draft.

2014 -
Pick 5 - DeGoey (fail)

The following were available to us and will be better players than DeGoey:
6- Caleb Marchbank
8- Peter Wright
10- Nakia Cockatoo
14- Jake Lever

I just think we overlooked too much class and went with DeGoey who was a hard nut, but footy is about speed and class these days.

De Goey will be better than any of those in my opinion.

[Daddy]

I think you are all blaming the wrong person for our decline. The trades and draft would all be done with who the coach wants,but I wouldn't be surprised if most of the selections can actually play. NEW COACH A.S.A.P

[CarringbushCigar]

Looks like Pert and Maguire are shafting another premiership hero in order to cover up our coach's appalling people skills. 2016 may be remembered for the exit of Hine Cloke and Brown and retaining the most failed coach in the history of our football club.

It's a disgrace.