ODI 3: India won toss, elected to field.
Oz 0/121 (19).
Khawaja 50 (56).
Finch 64 (58 ).
T20 & ODI tour of India.
Some discussion surrounding the Finch LBW review...
They think it was a bad review. They think it was out.
But... they don't trust what Hawk Eye claimed (middle & leg).
They think it just clipped leg.
Must look for replays.
Ahh, as quick as a flash, Raunak Kapoor has it up:
https://twitter.com/RaunakRK/status/1103965332362805248
Oh... this looks very bad. Very, very bad.
They say -- and the video clip seems to confirm it -- Hawk Eye is showing it pitching in a completely wrong place. Yeah, it's being accused of getting wrong the bit that we have full info on, not just the projection past the pad!
Adding to the confusion, fake Hawk Eye seems to show it clipping leg, as real humans claim... (And it's also been noted that this does have some practical relevance to this game, because if it's just clipping the outside of leg stump then the review is not lost.)
And another thing: Someone in the comments to the tweet above says the "same thing" happened to reprieve Tendulkar against Pakistan in the 2011 WC.
They think it was a bad review. They think it was out.
But... they don't trust what Hawk Eye claimed (middle & leg).
They think it just clipped leg.
Must look for replays.
Ahh, as quick as a flash, Raunak Kapoor has it up:
https://twitter.com/RaunakRK/status/1103965332362805248
Oh... this looks very bad. Very, very bad.
They say -- and the video clip seems to confirm it -- Hawk Eye is showing it pitching in a completely wrong place. Yeah, it's being accused of getting wrong the bit that we have full info on, not just the projection past the pad!
Adding to the confusion, fake Hawk Eye seems to show it clipping leg, as real humans claim... (And it's also been noted that this does have some practical relevance to this game, because if it's just clipping the outside of leg stump then the review is not lost.)
And another thing: Someone in the comments to the tweet above says the "same thing" happened to reprieve Tendulkar against Pakistan in the 2011 WC.
Last edited by K on Fri Mar 08, 2019 8:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
