Post Match. Pies whack West Coast. All comments please.
Moderator: bbmods
-
3rd degree
- Posts: 14200
- Joined: Tue Jun 22, 2004 12:50 pm
- Location: John Wren's tote
- Been liked: 1 time
- Contact:
I'm wondering again what Allen's exact size is, because on the Nic Nat injury the media news says Allen could do some rucking:Pies2016 wrote:Allen started on the ground and pretty sure he got Maynard. Allen didn’t stay on long and then they brought on Cameron. ...K wrote:Did WHE start at the first bounce on Allen or was he moved back only after Moore went down? (i.e. was this a planned move or improvisation?) What was the re-shuffle when Moore went down?Pies4shaw wrote:...
Where the 'pies really improved from last week, though, was with ground-ball and run inside (and from) the defensive 50. The small West Coast forwards barely touched the ball in the last hour of the game. That was mainly because we played WHE on their medium marking target (so, if he couldn't mark the ball, he was never going to touch it on the ground), ...
Allen looks to me larger than he is, if you believe the official numbers (192cm, 87 kg), but WHE's still much smaller.
...
Moore went down and Maynard moved to Darling but at the same time Cripps went off, so both teams had to shuffle their team around in the same part of the ground.
Pretty sure W H E started forward, albeit briefly but the two early injuries threw both teams out and it took a while for the dust to settle on the right match ups. W H E certainly put some time into Allen on occasions but they were at their most dangerous when Cameron replaced Allen early in the game.
...
"The man who benefited most from that injury, premiership ruckman Nathan Vardy, is still sidelined, leaving mature recruit Keegan Brooksby as next man up, although the Eagles could reluctantly use Oscar Allen as backup to incumbent recruit Tom Hickey, despite his recent dominance up forward."
^^^
K, we can only go by what the records say about his height but he was drafted as a mobile tall forward. He only played forward in the championships and I would seriously doubt if he does more than a few minutes rucking for them.
He’s a good player but when Cameron came on and got off the chain after replacing him, Allen seemed to either be on the pine or playing further up the ground after quarter time.
As P4S has already mentioned, when we lost Moore and Maynard went to Darling, it was a game changer. Not only did Maynard nullify him in the air but he smashed him at ground level.
K, we can only go by what the records say about his height but he was drafted as a mobile tall forward. He only played forward in the championships and I would seriously doubt if he does more than a few minutes rucking for them.
He’s a good player but when Cameron came on and got off the chain after replacing him, Allen seemed to either be on the pine or playing further up the ground after quarter time.
As P4S has already mentioned, when we lost Moore and Maynard went to Darling, it was a game changer. Not only did Maynard nullify him in the air but he smashed him at ground level.
Gary Player “ the harder I practice, the luckier I get “
-
E
is Nic Nat injured? Who was it who criticized the pies for its gentle approach with Shaz and used Nic Nat as an example?K wrote:I'm wondering again what Allen's exact size is, because on the Nic Nat injury the media news says Allen could do some rucking:Pies2016 wrote:Allen started on the ground and pretty sure he got Maynard. Allen didn’t stay on long and then they brought on Cameron. ...K wrote: Did WHE start at the first bounce on Allen or was he moved back only after Moore went down? (i.e. was this a planned move or improvisation?) What was the re-shuffle when Moore went down?
Allen looks to me larger than he is, if you believe the official numbers (192cm, 87 kg), but WHE's still much smaller.
...
Moore went down and Maynard moved to Darling but at the same time Cripps went off, so both teams had to shuffle their team around in the same part of the ground.
Pretty sure W H E started forward, albeit briefly but the two early injuries threw both teams out and it took a while for the dust to settle on the right match ups. W H E certainly put some time into Allen on occasions but they were at their most dangerous when Cameron replaced Allen early in the game.
...
"The man who benefited most from that injury, premiership ruckman Nathan Vardy, is still sidelined, leaving mature recruit Keegan Brooksby as next man up, although the Eagles could reluctantly use Oscar Allen as backup to incumbent recruit Tom Hickey, despite his recent dominance up forward."
-
Abdul The Bull
- Posts: 457
- Joined: Wed Aug 02, 2017 4:03 pm
I agree. They were telling moments. Checkers' mark in particular was enormous. I sensed he knew it, too. The way he waved the ball after the clean mark signaled, at least to me, that he knew that was the match won.matrix10 wrote: Cox and Mihocek marks were enormous also.
Much more enjoyable watching replay than actual game!
Stirring stuff.
There are 10 types of people in this world, those that understand binary and those that don't.
There’s a couple teams who have put their long time play makers out to the wing. Selwood and McRae ( and another one who escapes me ) have spent big chunks on the wing. You have to bat deep in the midfield in the first place to be afforded that luxury. I’m guessing the wings have become so important with 6 6 6, clubs want their best players available to support more in the back half.RudeBoy wrote:Interestingly, Jonathon Brown last night mentioned that Pendles played mainly on the wing, with Crisp in the middle. Watching on TV I hadn't realised that. Maybe it's a sign of what's to come with our team going forward.
If Crisp continues his form and Adams makes a successful comeback, we may very well see more of Pendlebury standing the line at centre bounces.
Last edited by Pies2016 on Tue Jul 16, 2019 8:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
eddiesmith
- Posts: 12396
- Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2004 12:21 am
- Location: Lexus Centre
- Has liked: 11 times
- Been liked: 24 times